Spread the cost interest free and pay in 3 instalments

Should I Choose a Yellow Gold or White Gold Engagement Ring?

The age old question when it comes to engagement rings is white, or yellow gold. With both metals being at the forefront of wedding jewellery, it is hard to decide which one to settle on.

Should I Choose a Yellow Gold or White Gold Engagement Ring?

With a multitude of advantages that come with both, it is almost impossible to know if you’re making the right decision, and since we can’t have both, this blog post will break down all the important points that relate to both white and yellow gold engagement rings. By presenting the pros and cons for both metals, and showcasing the differences and similarities between each, we will help you reach a decision so you can choose an engagement ring for you or your partner that will last throughout your perfect love story. 

Yellow gold engagement rings 

Yellow gold jewellery has had a huge jump in popularity recently, and for stylish brides-to-be with a penchant for all things eye-catching, there simply is no comparison. It is a metal type that has proved popular since its early discovery and the beauty of this metal has much to do with it. 

Yellow Gold Engagement Ring

Yellow gold is made up by mixing pure gold with other metals such as silver, copper, nickel, zinc, and palladium. From these metals, yellow gold possesses the highest concentration of copper which is what gives the metal its yellow-gold colour. This makes it highly durable and long-lasting which is always ideal for engagement rings. 

A yellow gold engagement ring is also perfectly suited to any bride, from the minimalist, maximalist and lover of traditional, to the vintage obsessed. Diamonds and precious stones such as red rubies and green emeralds look incredible set with yellow gold rings as the finish is warm and bright which really enhances the bright stone colours. 

For those who seek traditionalism in their wedding jewellery, look no further than yellow gold. Its beautiful vintage aesthetic makes it a timeless choice and adds a classic touch, for an engagement ring that oozes glamour and makes for a perfect heirloom to pass through generations. 

What’s more, the metal is much easier to resize than white gold because it is softer and does not require rhodium plating. Therefore, if your fingers naturally change size over time, or you accidentally damage your ring, rest assured your yellow gold ring is easy to repair. However, be mindful that because it is softer, it is slightly more prone to scratches and therefore won’t take well to those with a very active lifestyle, unless removed or regularly serviced. 

White gold engagement rings 

White gold is a continuously popular choice for engagement rings as the metal type is so versatile and suits every skin tone beautifully. It has a timeless, clean style that pairs perfectly with white diamonds. It is a great choice for any bride-to-be seeking a modern look and wants to showcase the brilliance of the diamond. 

White Gold Engagement Ring

White gold, like yellow gold, is made up of pure gold that is mixed with other alloys to give pure gold its hardness and robustness so that it can be moulded into jewellery. White gold specifically, is made from pure gold mixed with coloured alloys, such as nickel and zinc. These coloured alloys are what give the white gold its pale cool tone. Once the mixing process is complete, the metal then gets plated in rhodium to achieve the final white lustre. This process also means that the brand-new condition of white gold will last longer than yellow gold as it is more durable and less likely to be prone to scratching. 

However, metals can tarnish over a period of time, meaning white gold jewellery can become dull, despite its rhodium plating. If you do not get the ring cleaned and polished regularly, the rhodium plating may wear off, and if your white gold has been mixed with the nickel alloy, those with allergies may find the ring irritating on the skin. Although, it is always possible to specify a white gold ring that contains no nickel to prevent any reactions. 

Browse our collection of white gold engagement rings today. 

Yellow Gold vs White Gold Comparison 



 Yellow Gold Engagement Rings

White Gold Engagement Rings


  • Vintage aesthetic 
  • Easy to maintain 
  • Inexpensive and often unproblematic resizing 
  • Durable 
  • Timeless style 
  • Pairs well with coloured gemstones
  • Boasts an expensive, platinum-like look 
  • New condition lasts longer than yellow gold 
  • Durable 
  • Modern style 
  • Timeless style 


  • Prone to scratching 
  • Not very modern 
  • Prone ttarnishing 
  • Can contain nickel 
  • Requires more maintenance than yellow gold to replate the rhodium coating

Which should you choose?

Hopefully, now you are armed with all the important knowledge you need to help you make your all important decision. If you are a lover of traditional and classic style, and want to showcase your vintage love, then a yellow gold engagement ring is unrivalled. Or, if you want a sleek and modern option and wedding jewellery that is understated but bright, then white gold is the undisputed choice. Whichever you choose, the ring you decide on will be the one that best suits you or your partner's unique personality and style. Overall, both white and yellow gold rings will give you a timeless ring that will last a lifetime. 

If you’re still unsure, you can get in touch with our expert team at Browns for more information and advice to help you make your decision. Do not hesitate to contact us as we are happy to help you through all your queries.